I previously discussed a paper by Bruce Waltke (posted on the Biologos website) in which he stated:
The organizations seeking to refute evolution and/or to narrow the gap between creation and evolution must address one another with respect and openness to be optimally effective. The gap between BioLogos and ID, I suggest, can best be narrowed by open dialogue, not by entrenched confrontation.
In a footnote to that, he added:
In a personal correspondence, one highly respected scholar—were it otherwise, I would not cite him– wrote that it is alleged that Collins will not publicly engage an adherent of anti-evolution ID; he further suggested that if this is not so, Collins should make this clear.
Ironically, Waltke’s paper was published in connection with a Biologos conference to which no prominent ID proponents were apparently invited.
Stephen Meyer and his colleagues invited Francisco Ayala to a debate. Maybe this would be a good first start?